Wow. Thanks for the fast responses.
To answer some of your questions:
This motor has a 23″ shaft length and I have a 20″ transom. I looked up how to get this measurement and measured it. I was actually surprised because I didn’t know there was anything in tiller steer except 15 and 20″.
This is a 2 stroke motor…Nissan NS40C. The guys at the boat shop did a thorough check on everything and said that compression is excellent (135) and, mechanically, everything is as it should be. They were the ones that asked if I had the right prop, which led to me buying the one I did.
The prop I bought is actually the one recommended for this motor under a “heavy load”. I got the specs off the Nissan/Tahotsu website. BTW, a heavy load is considered anything over 1500 lbs. Since I usually have at least 2 guys in it and I’ve customed out the inside (adding a lot of weight), I figure I’m probably pushing 2000 lbs.
So….since this is a 2 cylinder, I’d assume that if one cylinder was “dropping out”, it would be noticeable. Engine runs smooth, even on plane. The issue is, it runs like you’re at half throttle.
I’ve read some posts that say running the motor too deep has a significant affect, whereas others say that it’s hardly noticeable where RPMs are concerned. I don’t know, I just want it to run right.
Am I wrong in assuming that a 40 hp 2 stroke should outperform a 25 hp 2 stroke?