On my way to work driving up the North Shore a few years ago, I saw a buck that I had been hunting dead on the side of the road. Nothing huge, but it was a nice, tall 8 pt. that I had seen from my stand but could never get a shot. I wanted the rack to make some rattling antlers for my dad cause I know he wanted some, but didn’t want to ruin any of his racks in the process. I called the local CO and told him what I wanted to do and asked how to proceed. He met me at the spot about 30 mins. after I called him, gave me a possession tag, but told me I had to dispose of the carcass properly. There were no issues in my situation so maybe yours was a case of an over zealous CO? I’m not sure, but I know I’ll follow proper procedure to avoid any serious consequences.