I have the same boat with a Merc 115 CT and I use a 19 pitch Mercury Tempest Plus stainless prop. It’s worked well since I bought the motor in 2016 and I’ve always been pleased with the performance. The part number stamped on the prop is 48-825860.
Agree ! I had the same ..That prop worked great. PS: I just got talked out of the boat in August and got considerably more than I paid for it new in 2016.