I know it’s not a popular opinion, but color is the last thing I worry about. I always start with a VMC chandelier jig. That thing has been money for me. Works great to get down to deeper waters and love the action it has with a minnow head or even a full minnow. Also the small treble hook is great for hook sets. Rarely miss unless they are just tapping it.
I always start with one of those, but if they are picky, and sometimes they are, I downsize to just a jig and a minnow. Then if I have to, a jig and plastic.
I always start aggressive and downsize if necessary. Try going out with a few buddies and all try different things. Makes it much faster to see what’s working that day than just by yourself. That’s how I go about it and I’ve had a lot of success so far this year.
Oh, and always, don’t be afraid to drill holes and move. Even if you are marking fish and can’t get them to bite, move to a different hole that has fish and see if those are more aggressive.