Depends on the day, the mood of the fish, and your confidence with what you have tied on.
When I feel unsure I tie something on and run one of each and let the fish be the judge.
Thursday meat was a clear winner from the menu.
Yeah it seemed like on Thurs people were mainly jigging minnows while slow-trolling/drifting or pitching plastics into the shorelines…personally I had the most luck with a heavier (1/4-3/8 oz.) FireTiger Thumper Jig and minnow, trying to entice that “reflex” bite as lots of bait fish were still on the scanner as mentioned above.