<div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>Pete S wrote:</div>
I can’t tell, was your tongue firmly embedded in your cheek when you typed this? when you say people from out of state would die to hunt in MN, what’s stopping them? maybe your job title has the initials D-N-R in it somewhere??? No offense, no one that I know that hunts WI ever says “boy I wish our deer herd compared to MN” Iowa and Illinois yes, MN-sorry.
Before we go too far down the “Woe Was Us” road, I have to ask: Do you currently hunt in any of the states the you point to as Deer Nirvanas?
I personally know a LOT of northern Wisconsin wishes that they HAD a deer heard. At all. Weather it compares to Minnesota, Mississippi, or Michigan, matters not, anything would be an improvement over the crashes they’ve had in some areas in northern WI. So while things aren’t perfect here, it could and is worse in some other states.
Sure, we’d all like to hunt the monsters in IA, IL, IN, etc, but the one thing holding most people back is that it’s all well and good to have huge deer, but unless you own a private farm down there or know somebody who does, it can be a LOT harder to actually HUNT anything, especially as a non-resident in those states. It certainly is nowhere near as simple as in MN where even a non-resident can buy an OTC tag.
So many people in MN have vastly more land to hunt available to them due to our large amounts of public land here in MN. It does you no good to have huge deer and good numbers if you can’t get access to an land to hunt them.
Great comment by Grouse. I grew up in Iowa and have hunted there for many years. The area that I grew up in had small wood lots, little public land, and smaller size farms relative to the larger parcels in the southern part of the state. Iowa is the mecca of deer hunting for many hunters, but the entire state of Iowa does not have 150″ bucks behind every tree. In fact, within my family and a combined 50 years of whitetail hunting between 4 people 149″ is the best deer any of us have ever harvested. With any game species the top end trophy animals relate to ideal habitat and management practices. The largest deer I have ever seen on the hoof occured the first year I moved to Minnesota on a small chunk of public land in Olmstead Co. With some slight changes to the season structure (moving the gun season out of the seeking and chasing phase of the rut) I think we can have our cake and eat it too (improved buck age structure, that are accesible to the majority of hunters through the fast public lands of MN.