I fished Elephant about a month ago and the fishing was extremely slow. Did well on walleyes, but the crappie and smallie bite was next to non-existant. The few smallies we did catch were on tubes or Rattltraps. Someone obviously did better than we did on smallies as I found three carcasses in the cleaning shack that were obviously all too big to keep. Anyhow, other than the far north bay most of the bays are your typical rocky/boulder substrate, a few with good weed growth mixed in. The far north bay had a nice classic boulder pile in it, but other than that was nothing more than a shallow bay full of loon [censored] and small stunted sunnies. We also worked the piling area and did well on walleyes…using 1/8 oz mimic minnow heads and paddletails.
We stayed in the old log cabin at Melgeorges and I must say the place was nice, good and reasonably priced food, and great waitstaff. I was a little disappointed in the number of cabins and homes on the lake, however, as I thought it would be more of a getaway than it actually was.
I’ve heard Elephant can be a great lake, but our first trip didn’t reveal that. We are booked for a family vacation again this fall at Melgeorges for a week and hopefully fishing will be better then.
Oh, one other thing, be careful if you anchor off the major point on the south end of the lake as I managed to catch my anchor twice (what are the chances of that?) on what I assume was an underwater electrical line in conduit. I was able to get my anchor back both times but just barely as that conduit gets extremely heavy when you pull it up from 20+ feet of water!