With the amount of people I know that do not have access to a boat, ice fishing is their get away time. Some people fish everyday in summer, but in reality I would have to say that there is way more fishing done on the ice in the short period of time the ice allows people to fish.
So I can see the negative effects on two lines through the ice. Heck I’ve done it successfully, and at one point I eve reeled up the second rod because I was sick of getting doubles.
I am mixed about the 2 lines. I support it, wouldn’t say I oppose it. People do it anyway, why not just make it legal, or as someone else stated, make it an option to buy a second license or some kind of stamp allowing you to use two.
As for us cat guys, there is a big difference from you bass, eye, and muskie guys. 99% of the guys I know who fish the river for cats, release 99% of their fish. VERY RARELY do I see or hear of anyone keeping a fish. If they do they are small. The only time I have ever seen a large fish taken out of the river was from people who had know clue what they were doing to that fish. They either take it home, or to the launch to show a bunch of buddies and than simply throw the fish in the water as the current takes the fish away.
I am sure if all the cat guys came out of the wood work and showed numbers as to how many fish they caught on the river in a year you’d probably see a 99% success rate in CPR from most of them. Even more so people like myself who release 100% of my catfish.
I know most or probably of you muskie guys release your fish as well. I bet if fishing for muskie didn’t require skills, and certain techniques most of you would be all for two lines.
I am fine with keeping lakes a 1 line rule. As for the people who are so against this. I know several people who don’t fish walleyes, don’t fish bass, and don’t fish muskie. But never once have they voted against something that is going to benefit that type of angler. I understand catfish is pretty low on the totem pole compared to other species. But to some people, it is their passion, their joy in their life to go out fishing for cats.
Maybe if there is a next meeting about two lines, instead of bashing and not caring about the lower species, maybe suggest rivers and streams be allowed two lines thus still protecting your inland waters with 1 line rule.