I can only help with one side of the choice. I ran a 2015 1880 last year and thoroughly enjoyed it. I sold it because I fish Sakakawea a lot and wanted to get into a 20 foot boat. I also loved the boat because it was powered by yamahas. You can still find them out there, but they’re unicorns.
Pros:
Ranger Reliability
Fishability was second to none
52 mph in an 18 foot boat is fantastic
comfortable to put my family in for a day of fun
Cons:
storage; you only had the two front lockers for gear, a two spot tray under the passenger console, and one compartment on the stern. I probably have more tackle than I should, but I basically had to choose between 10 boxes or haul around a tackle bag with me.