What a difference a year makes. Indy has been one of our mainstay metro lakes for years, but last year we began to see the effect of fishing pressure from the lake’s increased popularity. It’s not Buffalo Lake “city”, yet, but the bite has certainly suffered the past two ice seasons from extensive fishing pressure and recreational use. I’ve been out three times this year and between all of us we’ve caught a handful of baby eyes and perch, and we’ve been to all the key spots. From talking to others we’re not alone, but it sounds like the North point has been giving up a few of the nicer fish.
Indy is a great lake, but this year patience and determination might be your best strategies. We HAVE had good luck in numbers and fish size at Washington (Meeker) and Tonka. Simple presentations with fatty heads have worked best for us.
Good luck!