I’ve been shooting a Benelli Super Black Eagle, synthetic and camo for the past few seasons. Prior to that I shot a Remington 1100 for over 20 years. The Super Black Eagle was an expensive gun (about $1100) but when you only buy a new gun ever 20 years the cost per year is pretty low.
I like the weight and balance of the Benelli SBE better than the Remington 1100 but my records indicate I shoot about the same. At the end of the pheasant season I will have retrieved about 85% of the roosters I’ve shot at. I’ll hit about 3-5% that I don’t retrieve, either birds that get knocked down but we can’t find or birds that get hit and keep flying, and I just plain miss the rest. These figures are birds shot at, not shots fired. Sometimes I have to shoot twice and once this year it took three shots
I bought the SBE because it could handle anything from light 2 3/4″ loads up to heavy 3 1/2 loads. I’ve found this to be true. I haven’t had any problems. However, I’m dissappointed with the turkey loads I’ve patterned with this gun. I tried Federal 3″, 2 oz. #4 buffered loads and Federal 3 1/2″ loads and did not get what I consider to be a very tight pattern using the full choke. I also tried the improved modified choke thinking maybe the constriction was too tight in the full but that resulted in an even more open pattern. For turkey hunting I use my dad’s Mossberg pump and it shoots a much tighter pattern with the Federal 3″ load than the SBE. I measured the diameters of the choke tubes and the SBE tube had a slightly smaller diameter. One other thing I’ve noticed with my SBE is that the matte camo has developed a shine where it rubs against my hunting jacket or where I hold it.
Boone