Once you really take a look at the size of the shad a 5# walleye tend to urp up in your boat, often much larger than an adult man’s hand, you start to look at those 2″ tails as more of a single stale cracker than a full blown meal to these fish. Even a 5″ – 6″ tail is small by comparison. Its all about perspective I guess.
Fish these larger baits and you will catch fewer fish than you would running jig/minnow. Guaranteed. But the ones you do catch! Much nicer. And we still usually see 20-40 fish a day on a good day.
James Holst
Moving Waters Guide Service
http://www.movingwaters.net