James and all.. thanks for sharing all your experience!! this is why this board is such a great place to learn….. hopefully some fisheries bioligist are tuned into this… might give them some research ideas……
I too have seen walleyes in shallow but dormant…. I KNOW they will sit there and just NOT feed, the only exception would be if something were to fall in their lap that they were convinced was food…….
when I worked for the DNR at Clear Lake Iowa we had large aquariums with various fish speicies in them…. I managed to be the one to get to feed them (well some would say HAD to feed them… but I was fascinated!!)…… anyway it was my job to acquire food and provide it to our fish……. it was interesting to see the different reactions that the different species had.. they WERE segregated so the only competition was intra-species….. not a suprise.. but if you tossed bait in the the white bass tank…. boom… instant feeding frenzy!!! if you tossed it into the crappie tank the hunt was on immediatly!….. the bass tank.. pretty much the same…. though not QUITE instant.. within a short period of time they were feeding…..
the northern tank…. now they were an enigma!…. sometimes there was no change what so ever.. they continued to just sit there…. othertimes you would see them start to yawn and “stretch” then in a move so fast you almost could not follow it.. they practically teleported to where their target was and scales flew everywhere!!! amazin how fast they move when they “strike”….. nothing else like it!!
but the walleyes…. now they were the funniest…. I could never quite figure them out…. they were almost never READY to go… they were motionless on the bottom of the tank…. and sometimes the minnows would actually hide around them like they were logs!! when I turned off the tank lights they would slowly start to “yawn” and stretch… then they would start to creep up on some bait… and just open their mouth and suck it in… kind of dissappointing to watch!! but I KNOW they can be MUCH more active and aggressive than that…!! Ive seen it… but most of the time they were “dormant” and you were not going to catch them…… did I ever angle for these fish? YES….. not with bait.. of course…. never did catch a walleye out of the tank….. they just did not get excited over plastics in that environment….. now white bass, crappies and bass on the other hand….. !! but the pike also were NOT interested…. they wanted only live food and would ignore ANYTHING else……
ok… geez Im boring you by now…..
thanks for the river temp posts.. and light posts….. great stuff…..
it looks like we can safely say….
1. Walleye dont move in response to temps (unless they are stressfully high!, then I predict they would)…
2. Walleye dont move in response to light penetration (though I would still guess if there was a shady spot in the area they might favor it?)
3. Dont be afraid to try very shallow for them…. (but I would think that light reducing factors would enhance their activity level!! waves, mud lines, clouds, rain, perhaps available shade)….
now questions…..
just what sort of shallow areas do you look for?
is it just simply rip rap?
is it a large shallow flat?
a small flat with deeper water close by,
is there current, or no current?