I use regular rail type tip-ups for perch and crappies with no problems at all as long as they don’t have a notched “T” at the top of the spool. Those that do have a bit too much resistance for my liking. I also use those First Strike doohickeys and they work well also but when holes are freezing up I prefer a typical tip-up where the spool is underwater.
I carry a pile of tip-ups along when targeting perch and set them up like a dead stick rod. Jigging spoons, horizontal jigs, small trebles, etc. tied onto 18 inches or so of 4lb mono. I also have a set of tip-ups (stick type) set up for bluegills.
Tip-ups are very underutilized for panfish and allow you to efficiently cover a ton of water. They are great for schooling fish like perch. Put a spread of tip-ups out and flags popping up will give you a clear picture of how schools are cycling through an area allowing you to stay in front of them better than by simply hole hopping.