I’ve got the bull whip and two thorne bros, panfish sweetheart and quiver stick both with trip wires. I agree with will that the noodle is my preference when it comes to a visual bite, but on the flip side, I do like that I have a very nice sensitive graphite blank to feel the fish, and if it does get tough, I can switch over to the spring bobber. If you fish outiside a lot, the tripwire can be hard to fish, and a noodle rod would be the ticket, but, if you do want something that is more versatile, and end up going with the tripwire, think about getting the second heaviest spring out of the three choices, it will help fishing outside the trap. Good luck