http://www.jsonline.com/news/state/jan06/385648.asp
Conceal-carry bill back to governor
By STEVEN WALTERS
[email protected]
Posted: Jan. 17, 2006
Madison – The Legislature for the second time on Tuesday sent Democratic Gov. Jim Doyle a bill that would legalize the carrying of concealed weapons, but the governor promised to again veto the measure.
By passing the bill (SB 403) on a 28-5 vote, however, the Senate has far more than the two-thirds majority needed to override a veto. How a veto override would fare in the 99-member Assembly remains uncertain.
On Dec. 14, the Assembly passed the measure 64-32, or two votes shy of the 66 needed for a veto override. Republicans say they hope to have the 66 votes necessary to override Doyle’s expected veto, because two GOP legislators were not present to vote on that day.
But Democrats say they remain optimistic that Doyle’s veto would withstand the override attempt, hinting that one of several Democrats who voted for the bill in mid-December may change course and support the governor the next time.
Two years ago, the Senate voted to override Doyle’s first veto of a measure legalizing concealed weapons, but the Assembly fell one vote short of doing so.
Wisconsin is one of four states that do not allow the carrying of concealed weapons. The others are Kansas, Nebraska and Illinois.
Sponsors said their bill would deter crime and allow law-abiding citizens to defend themselves, their families and their property.
“Never has this law been repealed in any other state that has it,” said Sen. Dave Zien (R-Eau Claire), the chief Senate advocate of the bill.
But Sen. Bob Jauch (D-Poplar) said: “There is absolutely no evidence that this bill will reduce crime. . . . It doesn’t make us safer. It creates more problems.”
“Police officers are against the bill, because it is anti-law enforcement,” said Sen. Fred Risser (D-Madison), who noted that the law would not allow officers responding to domestic disputes to know whether someone in the home has a concealed weapons permit.
Some compromises
In a late compromise added by the Assembly on Dec. 13, however, police officers could learn whether drivers they stop in traffic cases have a concealed weapons permit.
That same compromise also required renewal of concealed weapons permits every five years and lowered – from 0.08 to 0.02 – the maximum blood-alcohol content for someone legally carrying a weapon. It also enacted a 100-foot, weapons-free zone around school property and made it a felony to falsely apply for a permit.
The bill would prohibit concealed weapons in police stations and sheriff’s departments, in prisons and in jails, and in taverns or restaurants, if food makes up less than 50% of their gross annual sales.
The measure would require retailers and other businesses to post signs warning customers that concealed weapons are not allowed in those businesses. Employers could prohibit concealed weapons in their buildings but could not ban them from the private vehicles of employees.
The bill would not make public the names of people issued concealed-weapons permits. Government watchdog groups insist such disclosure is needed as a check to make sure that permits are issued appropriately and to determine whether the measure increases or decreases public safety.
Five senators who voted against the bill in December backed the Assembly compromise on Tuesday. Those five are: Republican Sen. Luther Olsen of Ripon; and Democratic Sens. Tim Carpenter of Milwaukee, Judy Robson of Beloit, Jon Erpenbach of Middleton and Dave Hansen of Green Bay.
Five other Democratic senators stood by their earlier votes against the bill. They were Spencer Coggs and Lena Taylor, both of Milwaukee; Mark Miller of Madison; and Jauch and Risser.
The Legislative Fiscal Bureau estimated that up to 37,000 Wisconsin residents would apply for permits in the first year, if the measure becomes law. That is less than 1% of all Wisconsin residents older than 21, according to state demographers.
Those applying for a Wisconsin permit would pay $75 – a $52 application fee; $15 shooting range fee for required firearms training; and $8 background check fee.
Doyle has repeatedly said that allowing citizens to carry concealed weapons would make Wisconsin less safe, and he will “absolutely” veto the bill again, according to aide Melanie Fonder.
The vote underscored the rift between Doyle and Republicans, who control the Legislature. The vote came only hours before the governor’s annual “state of the state” speech – the last one before his re-election bid this fall.