Still grinding it out

  • sticker
    StillwaterMN/Ottertail county
    Posts: 4418
    #1693571

    I have had no luck with getting a Tom with the bow yet, but I am still grinding it out. I have learned one thing this year though. I am burning my strutting jake decoy. Last night was the 3rd time I had a tom hang up out of range and not wanting to challenge the jake. I understand this earlier in the season, but by now I would think with hens nesting that competition for hens would be a higher priority than getting your butt kicked.

    I had 2 hen decoys and a strutting jake decoy in the small plot about 20 yards from me. After about 20 minutes of me calling every 10 minutes a hen answers. I thought to myself, call her in and the tom will follow, so I did. She was all by herself and came right into the hen decoys and proceeded to call for 10 minutes. I looked at my watch, so it felt like an hour but was actually 10 minutes. She was calling very loud and often and all of a sudden from across the 60 acre field next door I hear a gobble. She called a few more times and he was coming. He came all the way across and to about 40 yards, then hung up when he saw my strutter jake decoy. Again, I had looked at my watch so I know how long all of this lasted. For over an hour he stayed 40 yards out strutting while she walked around me and the decoys. He would never come any closer even though twice the hen got within 10 yards of my stand and dropped to her belly in the breeding position. He just stayed there and strutted. Finally the hen got bored and walked off. The tom stayed there about 10 more minutes and strutted but still would not come closer. I had no way of getting a shot thru the trees with the bow. He also got bored and headed back the way he came. Needless to say I am done with the strutting jake decoy. flame

    haleysgold
    SE MN
    Posts: 1453
    #1693595

    I’m curious. Do have any strings attached to that jake decoy?
    I’ve seen them work very well but usually have strings tied to them so they can make it move.
    Once the Tom saw it move they were a bee line to kick some butt.
    Might be worth a try?

    404 ERROR
    MN
    Posts: 3918
    #1693616

    I’m curious. Do have any strings attached to that jake decoy?
    I’ve seen them work very well but usually have strings tied to them so they can make it move.
    Once the Tom saw it move they were a bee line to kick some butt.
    Might be worth a try?

    I second the string. I have used mono fishing line and it can really wake up wary Toms. Just don’t start yanking on the line when they’re getting within shooting distance.

    sticker
    StillwaterMN/Ottertail county
    Posts: 4418
    #1693617

    I don’t have any strings attached, but the wind was moving the decoy side to side some.

    haleysgold
    SE MN
    Posts: 1453
    #1693631

    I think it has to spin a bit. It seemed like when the Jake turned his backside to the Tom, that did it.
    Must be like mooning someone…kinda pisses ya off!

    sktrwx2200
    Posts: 727
    #1693634

    I always think the gobblers are like Whitetails in the fall.. There are just certain ones no matter age or hierarchy that are looking for a fight, and will investigate no matter what the situation.. and then some that just dont want to risk it no matter what time of year.

    Is this happening all year? or just this one time? Late in the season (NOW) I would continue to use the jake decoy with the hens if it were me. Just hens by themselves might signal to the gobbler that these hens are already on the nest.

    What strutting jake decoy do you have.. Is the full strut or 1/4 strut avian X? Maybe tone it down to just a standing jake and no strutting.

    Also late in the year I add in gobbles and fighting purrs calls to the mix to reinforce that the jake decoy means business. Adds to the realism. I have better luck bringing Gobblers in with Gobbler calls over hen vocalizations late in the year.

    sticker
    StillwaterMN/Ottertail county
    Posts: 4418
    #1693640

    Good info guys, thanks much. I will give this a try.

    I find it really hard to believe that even the live hen dropping to the ground in the breeding position wasn’t enough to make him come closer.

    super_do
    St Michael, MN
    Posts: 1085
    #1693652

    Don’t feel bad. I myself have spent 11 days out in SoDak without a decent shot. I’ve tried about every decoy combo you can think of including a taxidermy hen. I’m shooting the Magnus Bullhead so I have my decoys at 7-8 yards. I’ve had one tom come in, but he got nervous right away and quickly walked off. Thinking it might have been the blind flapping in the wind. It was howling that day. Going to give it one more shot the last weekend of the season out there. Good luck!

    Protourbaits1
    Posts: 191
    #1693754

    The Tom could be blind and/or decoy shy. I had 3 toms hang up between 25-40 yards last Saturday and I had the 1/4 strut avian x Jake and a bedded hen. The birds would gobble, strut and zig zag back and forth and finally lost interest.
    I was too afraid to move to the other corner of the blind to get a shot. Part of me was thinking they’d commit with only one hen and a Jake approaching her from behind, but they never did.
    I had the blind under a cedar and not brushed in like I usually do. This may have helped but I’ll never know. It’s hard with a bow….

    Nice Fella
    Posts: 457
    #1693916

    I find it really hard to believe that even the live hen dropping to the ground in the breeding position wasn’t enough to make him come closer.

    Even for a turkey, she must have been REALLY ugly!

Viewing 10 posts - 1 through 10 (of 10 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.