First, I would highly suggest you go to Mercury’s Website and use their prop selector just to get a feel.
That being said, I am in the same boat as my very reliable Optimax for 11+ seasons abruptly gave up the ghost at 6:18 AM Memorial day weekend and I was forced to repower.
Here are some thoughts for what others are using or is being suggested by Mercury. What works best for you will depend on the weight of your boat, and what you want from your prop. Max RPM / handling … keeping in mind your max RPM is 5800.
Bravo 1 FS
Enertia
Tempest Plus 19 – seems to be most popular, perhaps many come with it
Rev 4
High Five 21
I have kept my High 5 for now, and will be heading out to start break in shortly.
Paulski