I could be wrong, but I think B.C.’s looking for an explanation on your comment.
I can see when you’re fishing grass mats the hook up ratio may be higher because the jig won’t fall through the mat and out of the strike zone.
It’s different story in sparse “slop.” A missed strike can’t be nursed back like it can with a floating frog. I find my hook up ratio to be much better with a frog, whether it’s a Tournament Series Frog or a Stanley Ribbit. I have enough confidence that I know I can coax a bass to come back and hit a frog once or maybe twice after the initial strike.
With swim jigs, I find I have to keep casting at the area where the strike came from or follow up with an assortment of soft plastics.
Swim jigs are NOT in my confidence box. I use them, have an assortment of them, but rarely do I find myself relying on them. In slop or out.
Now, if you are talking about pulling tubes in slop weightless or lightly weighted. That my friend is horse of a COMPLETELY different color…