I would take a close look at the St. Croix warranty. Rod must be sent to the factory with a check. They look it over and determine how it broke. It’s the same with Fenwick. I dont know if they reimburse shipping and return the check if rhey deem the problem to be manufacture defect. You would be out shipping costs to use said Lifetime Warranty.
I broke my Fenwick EliteTech’s tip and the warranty would have replaced the rod for $90 after all expenses paid. Maybe not quite so bad being it was my fault, but to rich for my blood being the rod is still fish able. Scheels would only assist in shipping the rod. Fenwick and St. CROIX have the final say in how the rod broke and Scheels won’t be on the hook for a turned down warranty.
Keep your receipt too. Both warranties require it to get the max payout. St. Croix even requires you to register the rod for warranty.
I bought the Scheels rod based on the over-the-counter warranty. Definitely wasn’t my first choice of rods, but after seeing the hoops needed to jump through with the others in the $100-$200 range, I’ll stick local. Time may tell if Scheels is good for the warranty. The tags say Lifetime on manufacturer defects. Perhaps the days of no questions asked are long gone.