Ruger american w/vortex crossfire 3-9 would be a very comparable alternative.
A comparable alternative with possibly comparable issues.
I had to return a Vortex Crossfire last summer. It was bad out of the box, no amount of adjusting could make it maintain focus from shot to shot. After looking over the replacement the supplier sent, I thought the optical quality was very poor, even for a budget scope so I opted for a Bushnell at the same price and it has proved to be a much better scope.
In any rifle/scope combo, the scope is always where they cut corners. I love the Axis rifles but would never buy a pre-scoped package.
The Axis represents fantastic value per unit of accuracy. I have fired literally over 1000 rounds (yes, I keep an exact count) through my 2 Axis varminters and I have had only 2 issues. A case head seperated and left the case body in the chamber. An ice bath and cleaning rod with new brass brush took care of that. And the magazine’s retainer spring broke on my .223 Axis. Luckily Axis mags are easy to find and I found one that evening at a local gun shop.
The Ruger American if also a fine rifle, but comparing like to like levels of the respective product lines, it is generally more expensive than the Axis of the same level. So yes, of course, if you spend more you get more.
We have to keep in mind as well, that the average rifle owner fires a handful of rounds per year, IF even that. I honestly believe that my two shot-hard-and-put-up-wet Axis varmint rifles have already been shot more than the average rifle will be shot in its entire life.
Grouse