I had the same issue last year, I wanted new Xtratufs and searched locally. No dice. Nobody stocks the classic brown version.
I also didn’t realize that Honeywell bought the brand and moved production to China. Read about this online, but bottom line is Xtratuffs are now just the same as all the other cheap Chinese made boots. Bottom line is Honeywell started fixing what wasn’t broke and totally cluster ###### a storied brand.
Against my better judgement, I ordered a pair in size 11, same size I always wear, and they came and were so tight I had to send them back. I’d need at least a 12. I have since read online that sizes are all over the map as Honeywell tried to solve Chinese production issues. Some have said that sizing has returned to normal, I don’t know about that.
I ended up going with cheap boots that are now shot again. So pls be sure to post what you ended up doing.
BTW, I’m NOT looking for “muck” style neoprene boots. Those are way too hot. I just want old school rubber boats that last.
Grouse