Defining some Barbs

  • castandblast
    Eau Claire, WI
    Posts: 269
    #1319101

    The other day I caught a whole smorgasbord of Barb species. One of the most enjoyable things I do after a trip is to identify the species caught especially when they are new lifers. They were all caught using the same method: sight-fishing free falling small pieces of doughbait on a small hook. I found this really cool pond that holds the largest variety of species that I have ever seen over here.

    There is something about a falling bait that attracts fish. I have witnessed this on species back home too. Falling bait can work on tough biters. If nothing takes the bait, I let it sit for a moment and then do the fall from the top again. Falling bait triggers some species to bite and is deadly.

    All of the following specimens shown are large for their species. They are fun to catch and ID and all can be caught in an afternoon at this pond I found. This is not a paypond either but a small natural lake.

    Swamp Barb (Puntius orphoides)
    Max. size: 8 inches
    There are 8 Puntius species over here and are tough to ID. They will also make their way into rice paddies.

    Beardless Barb (Cyclocheilichthys apogon)
    Max. size: 7 inches
    This species likes ant eggs too.

    Longfin Carp (Labiobarbus lineatus)
    Max size: 7 inches
    This species feeds only once the bait hits the bottom. The very long dorsal is a give-away to ID. . I have seen the Longfin make a large migration when the rains come.

    Siamese Mud Carp (Henicorhynchus siamensis)
    Max size: 8 inches
    This species schools close together. They feed at mid-water levels as the bait is dropping.

    Dusky Face Carp (Osteochilus lini)
    Max size: 6 inches
    This is a very drab looking Barb, has barbells and primarily feeds on the bottom.

    Silver Sharkminnow (Osteochilus hasselti)
    Max size: 12 inches
    The pink marks behind the gills are the unique ID marks of this species. This is the biggest of all these species here. They are commonly netted in the thickest of weeds here. I was told by a Thai fisherman that I could not catch these with hook and line but he was wrong.

    theodorenugget
    Sugar Land, TX
    Posts: 609
    #846208

    Those are some really vivid colors. Great pics. It would be nice to find some flukes or plastics in colors this vivid here in Minnesota.

    robby
    Quad Cities
    Posts: 2821
    #846238

    So, how do they taste?

    hags54701
    Eau Claire, WI
    Posts: 113
    #846263

    Amazing variety…thanks for sharing.

    Shiny…I bet some of big, toothy gamefish would love to see them on the menu around here. Send some up….I’ll give them a try.

    mark-bruzek
    Two Harbors, MN
    Posts: 3863
    #846306

    Can you ship me a dozen of those, I think the eyes would love them. Espicially on Rainy River. -Mark

Viewing 5 posts - 1 through 5 (of 5 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.