We don’t have a great track record for finding that sweet spot, but I’ll reserve judgement on Fleck. Let’s see how things look in November.
Regardless of how things look this November, you cannot judge the success or lack thereof of a first year coach and coaching staff in the first year. No matter who it is. Even if they are 2-8, he should still be allowed to build or rebuild with his own recruiting and philosophy. Barry Alvarez at Wisconsin had one or two wins his first season and perhaps 3 or 4 in his second year. And we all know how that turned out.
Point being, when all you get is the mid level players thats all you will ever be is mid level. Talent wins, guys that can play and can’t spell cat get recruited.
Not always true…
Having outstanding head coach and coaching staff is more important when it comes to player development and working with and getting the most out of the talent that you have. Without high level coaching, 4 and 5 star recruits can play like walk-ons and make stupid mistakes on (or off) the field. Whereas mid-level players that are well coached, fundamentals, discipline, the game itself managed properly, getting these players to “play above their heads” is what builds a successful program. And once the program gains more success (wins) and earns the more “preferred” prime time bowl games, this is when more of the 4 and 5 star recruits take notice and then consider that program.
This is just how Barry Alvarez built the Badger football program back in the early 90’s, and now look at where they still are today…