It funny, I read these posts all the time, and I fall for it too. But my dad, 80+ still uses old jiggle sticks and pulls fish in hand over hand, with his 25 year old Vexilar, and has no issues catching fish, usually out fishes the group. Same in the summer Lindy rigging for Walleye, I use the latest, greatest setup, and he has his 30 year old Kmart special with 20lb mono line, and he lays his rod down on the boat, leans back and drinks beer until his rod moves, again catching as many or more than the group.
I am not saying technology, and spending the big bucks doesn’t help, just not sure it helps that much.
That said, I run Shimano Sienna’s on all my ice rods, never had any issues.