Abu Garcia’s Cardinal SX line of reels are worth a look too. I have the SX5 and the SX10. They have a pretty good drag system, IMO. They can both handle river smallie runs (20″+ smallies) no problem on my 1-4# ultra light. I HotSauce all my winter reels and haven’t had a problem yet (other than HotSauce leaking from the bottle). They are around $30-$40.
I’ve heard nothing but praise for the Tica Cetus. I have a Tica Libra 3000 I use as a summer bass reel then use it as a winter pike reel. Tica makes nice stuff.
Any of the mentioned Shimano’s will work well also although I believe they have discontinued the 500 series for the Sienna and the Sahara.
Things I look for in any reel (spinning) that are a must, regardless of price or size, is a legitimate functional instant anti-reverse with absolutely zero play, a smooth drag, and a decent feel on reeling (grinding, binding, etc). I usually strip my reels anyways so the latter is usually remedied by a thorough cleaning and a re-lube with what I feel is a better quality grease/lube, which is HotSauce grease and lube, no grease in the winter though, just lube. It’s been working out well for me since I started personally servicing my reels a few years ago.