Shadow Raps are one of my favorite trolling baits on Lake Superior, even though they are marketed/designed as a suspending jerk bait. Nothing mimicks a smelt better (in my opinion).
I agree their hooks are on the lighter side (which no doubt makes them so effective at catching fish), but I wouldn’t call them junk at any stretch. They’ve put fish weighing 1 pound to 25lbs in the net at trolling speeds hundreds of times for me.
When I get a bait that needs some love I replace them with 1X Gamakatsu round bend trebles. They’re a tad beefier but I don’t think they affect the action enough to make a significant difference (for my application anyway).
Shadow Raps have been put through the gauntlet for me, and I can honestly say I’ve never had a body break. Hooks have broken, split rings have pulled (both have mostly happened with a fish thrashing in the net), but I’ve never had a bill snap off or the hardware in the bait itself fail.