I still think that the entire property tax system is BS. Value is nothing more than perception. So someone down the street sells their home and someone agrees to overpay for it. I have no intention of selling my home, but the perceived value goes up because of their sale and its a comp to mine. Why? I built a home at a specific price point because it was at a level I could/wanted to afford. I haven’t gutted it out and added gold to it, haven’t put an addition on it, and everything in it is nearing its life cycle and depreciating.
Now, if I sell it and make a profit, I pay Capital Gains. Key there is Capital Gains. When I actually have a gain, I pay the appropriate tax on it – ONCE!! you shouldn’t be dinged a capital gain tax just because its renamed as a property tax.
Plus, why should you be penalized for improvements? I see some people let their homes go to crap. Literally falling apart. But they have 3/4 million dollars in toys parked on the property. Kind of funny and ironic in a way. Neighbor down the street argues his tax bill every year to get it reduced. Shows and proves that his house is a piece of crap. Yet he has his sailboat, lake MI boat, garage filled with new ATV’s, his over priced cars and so on. His property has more assets on it than mine – so why should I have a higher tax bill? How about a fair tax rate for the amount of land and not penalize a person for what they have on it.
Structure it for use, Residential 1, 2 , 3…Agriculture, Forestry, Recreational and have a reasonable rate. Then we don’t need the “improvement” values to bounce like a yo-yo and keep adjusting the mil rate.
Imagine this – you have 21,000 sqft of Res 1 land x $.11 = $2,310
I own 43,000 sqft x $.11 = 4730