So you’re suggesting that someone with a full pressure well system use an air over water tank?
It was how it was done years ago, they would water log and have to be drained and add air to the tank. With the bladder it helps keep more consistent pressure and fewer pump off and on cycles I had the plain tank and would never go back to it.
[/quote]
If you have to add air to an Air Over Water tank, either components have failed or the system was designed wrong. In an Air Over Water system, when the pump shuts off water if the upper drop pipe drains out of a bleeder valve. The resulting vacuum causes air to be drawn in through a schrader valve at the top of the drop pipe. When the pump kicks back on this air is pushed into the tank to replenish any air that may have been lost, excess air is released through the air volume control on the tank. Air is compressed until pump raises pressure to the cut off point and the system is now pressurized.