Forest Lake muskie rampage

  • carp chaser
    Twin Cities, MN
    Posts: 155
    #1312645

    Today was the final day for our fishing contest, so my brother and I decided to give it one last shot, for the mighty muskie since neither of us had tried for muskies this year. The reports we got from Mille Lacs were poor so we tried closer to home, on Forest L. First we stopped at the local creek and caught some bait (7/8″ chubs, golden shiner and small suckers). We arrived at our destination and it didn’t look very good, windy conditions, almost no boats on the water. We were determined to catch something though, so we started slow trolling in 15-25 feet with our live bait. After 5 minutes I had what felt like a crappie or perch bite, it was just strong enough to get my attention so I released line, which went out slowly and steadily. After a few minutes it stopped and I started reeling (not realizing I actually had something on.) It was a steady tension as I reeled but it couldn’t be a fish since it wasn’t even pulling back I thought. As it got closer to the boat I realized it was a fish, swimming towards me. Finally the beast surfaced, a 20 pound class muskie. Couldn’t believe it, seemed so surreal. I was so excited, my first muskie ever. Then a horrible site, as it saw the boat it took a dive and my bait floated to the surface (bait and hook came out since I had never even set the hook). It was so heart breaking. There goes my big chance at a muskie, I was not going to give up though. I threw my half-shredded chub back in, hoping for a miracle, and believe it or not, within about 2 minutes I had another strike. This time I let him have it for a long time- maybe 5 minutes. I finally set the hook and reeled in another muskie, much smaller than the first but still a muskie! A hair under 36″ (about 12 or 13 pounds). How’s that for fast action? Just proves you can’t give up!

    The day wasn’t over yet however. After releasing the water wolf, we went to a new location where some huge schools of bait fish were (and of course more muskies). We each missed a nice run within 45 minutes or so, then as we were about to leave, I had another small peck- (don’t be fooled), this “peck” lead to line being literally ripped off my reel. After a long patient wait I reeled up, the tension was there so I set as hard as I could, a much bigger fish on. It put up a heck of a fight. Good thing I had 50 lb. test, this monster was pulling like a freight train, taking out drag effortlessly. It took 4 or 5 minutes to tire him out, and then it just barely fit in the net. 40-1/4″ (estimated at 18-20 lbs.). This fish was so fat and extremely powerful, a real challenge to bring in. A very successful day, must be beginner’s luck. So we had 2 muskies landed, a third that got away and just as many bites… all within roughly 2 hours before sunset. A great way to end the contest.

    vern
    Richfield, MN
    Posts: 316
    #234556

    Hey Carpchaser! Sounds like a great day on the water. I’d love to see a list of all the species you caught for the contest. What was the oddest catch? Did you win? Vern

    carp chaser
    Twin Cities, MN
    Posts: 155
    #234564

    Going into Sunday I was tied for first, but after the surprising muskie I went into the lead by myself with 33 species. It wouldn’t be right if I didn’t thank all the people on this board that gave so many good tips, you helped me reach my goal of 30 species- and surpass it. We’ve been having this friendly competition since March, here’s the final results for the biggest fish of each species: (among 7 people)

    overall biggest fish:

    1. Flathead catfish 31 lbs. – 0 oz.

    2. Carp 20 lbs. – 6 oz.

    3. Lake Sturgeon 18 lbs.- 12 oz.

    by species:

    Bass, Largemouth 5 lbs. – 2 oz.

    Bass, Rock 8″

    Bass, Smallmouth 18-1/2″

    Bass, White 16-1/4″ (2 lbs.)

    Bluegill 9″

    Bowfin (dogfish) 6 lbs. – 15 oz.

    Bullhead, Black 12″

    Bullhead, Brown 8-3/4″

    Bullhead, Yellow 9-1/2″

    Carp, Common 20 lbs. – 6 oz

    Carp, Mirror 6 lbs. – 0 oz.

    Catfish, Channel 11 lbs. -6 oz.

    Catfish, Flathead 31 lbs. – 0 oz.

    Chub, Creek 8-1/2″

    Chub, Lake 6-1/4″

    Chub, Silver 4″

    Crappie, Black 10-1/4″

    Crappie, White 8-3/4″

    Hogsucker, Northern 14″

    Logperch 4″

    Mooneye 14-1/4″

    Muskie 40-1/4″

    Perch, Yellow 9-1/2″

    Pike, Northern 35″

    Pumpkinseed 6-9/10″

    Redhorse (various) 22″

    Sauger 12-1/2″

    Shad, Gizzard 12-3/4″

    Sheepshead 18-1/2″

    Shiner, golden 7″

    Splake NA

    Sturgeon, Lake 18 lbs – 12 oz

    Sucker, White 19-1/2″

    Sunfish, Green 5-1/2″

    Sunfish, Hybrid 5-1/4″

    Trout, Brook 9-1/2″

    Trout, Brown NA

    Trout, Lake NA

    Trout, Rainbow 18″

    Walleye 27″

    Next year I hope to add a few more to this list. Plus we are going to do it differently, each person will combine their 3 biggest fish (from 3 different species) for a total weight.

    fishhunter
    Stillwater, Minnesota
    Posts: 181
    #234567

    That is one HUGE list. Way to go. Congrats!!

    carp chaser
    Twin Cities, MN
    Posts: 155
    #234575

    thanks. It’s a long list but there’s still a few big ones missing, like gar, shovelnose sturgeon, eelpot, buffalo, tiger muskie, and salmon.

    Jack Naylor
    Apple Valley, MN
    Posts: 5668
    #234669

    way to go CarpChaser, thought I’d throw in a suggestion on your minnow/Muskie fishing. Check out the Quick Strike rigs for rigging you minnows. there is a big hook up front and a big trailer hook on the back end. you then do not need to wait at all in setting the hook, usually one of them will be in their mouth enough. in doing this you do NOT risk the chance of giving them too much line/ or time and hooking them too deep, which can easily kill a nice fish. It is not catch and release when releasing a fish with a fatal injury. good luck, and don’t forget the camera. Jack.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.