Acceptance of random search is (at best) difficult for me, as those who talked with me at the get-together probably could have guessed.
The “if your not doing anything wrong you have nothing to fear” argument is bogus. I’m sure that we would all be willing to carry cards that allow targeting of individuals by a space-based death-ray which allows the president to eliminate “problem citizens,” either.
Police powers are granted by the people during times when they have nothing to worry about – then abused by those who come to power at a later date. In the above example, none of us really have anything to worry about, until the next Bill Clinton gets elected and has a button created that’s simply labeled “NRA members.”
Consider also the following example: A man sues the DNR for harassment. His case is seemingly quite strong, as every Saturday morning, the DNR is waiting outside his house when he wakes up. They follow him to the ramp, and search his truck. Nothing. He heads out fishing. Every hour, on the hour, the CO stops him and tears his boat apart looking for an illegal fish. When he gets fed-up and heads back to the ramp, the CO searches his boat again – nothing… searches his truck again… nothing… makes him empty his pockets and pats him down… nothing… follows him home, enters the house, and checks the freezer… nothing.
When the judge asks the CO why, he can say, “Because I don’t like the guy,” and is still perfectly within the enforcement limits set forth. All this ruling does is say that everyone has to play by the same rules.
To say that more people will automatically do the wrong thing is questionable in my opinion as well – how many people currently take home their legal limit every time they go out fishing? The rapid spread of CPR is a credit to fishermen everywhere and a positive indicator that we are realizing that self-policing is an invaluable tool for sustained fisheries.