Over the past few years I’ve become an expert at pulling an Otter Lodge by hand… I’ve done it to get into some back country lakes with James up by Ely, early ice on Mille Lacs prior to ATV travel, into some back country trout lakes, and even for over 3/4 a mile up Superior in both the Duluth and Bayfield areas where I just didn’t feel safe on an ATV. The good news is that if you really crunch the numbers an Otter Lodge is actually lighter than virtually all comparable models as the lightweight seat mounting system makes up for the more rugged sled and canvas. The bad news is that you’re probably missing at least another 50 lbs in gear assuming you will be bringing an auger, rods, tackle, and some type of heater.
The short answer is yes, it is absolutely doable to pull your lodge in by hand. The long answer is that it is very very hard work especially if there is anything more than an 1-2″ of snow. Adding the hyfax to your sled helps quite a bit, but even then if there are more than a couple inches of snow and the hills are anything more than just a very gradual slope you will probably need to a a) either take all your gear out when you pull it up the hill or b) have a 2nd person pushing from behind. The shmitty sled works awesome on flat surfaces but you better have a well built shmitty sled and a way to strap your house tightly to the sled if you want to use it going up and down hills.
Now that Otter came out with the hub style houses this year I will be adding a hub and smaller Otter sled to my arsenal so that I can go lighter weight for exactly these types of trips.
Will