Be nice Fish, he’s a walleye guy.
Pug, after looking at the marks a little close I’m going with a gar.
Frequently they will grab a bait and make your line out alarm take of only to have them dropped when the hook is set. That picture is exactly what a sucker looks like when hit by a gar.
Snappers will (normally) take a bite out and softshells like to slowly swim away before eating your bait.
Switching to faster moving water or to bullheads will solve this problem.
HMmm, I get these short bite/chew marks here on the cedar a lot. No gar here and I think a turtle will eat the fins off rather than just chew it up like that. I’ve always thought that to be a flat head just chewing on the bait. I’ll agree that a flat head, just about any size, will easily eat a 6″ blue gill or 10″ sucker, but as I have said, I have a lot of these short bites. I’m sticking with mouthing flat heads.
I’m working on a solution…a quick strike rig of my own design. I plan to test it out this weekend so hopefull I will have an answer. Nothing will short bite this rig.
L8R…Ken