Got it!!! Everyone kept telling me it would be a voltage problem. Batteries bad, bad connection, etc. Then quite by accident I happened to notice a pinched place on the motors power cable. Turns out that somehow during packing, shipping, unpacking, installing, something sharp and heavy had been on the power cord and most of the strands in the negative wire were broken. The pinch was visible only on one side and you just about had to be looking directly at that side and that exact place to notice it.
I cut the wire and reattached the plug and the red LED was much brighter than before. The foot pedal works just as advertised and Minn Kota is sending me a new cable.
Thanks guys for the help.