I’ve fished for many years out of both types of boats, there are pro and cons of each. IMO, if you’re going to get a console boat, you might as well get the full windshield. They take up nearly the same amount of room and the benefit of a full shield wind block is priceless. What’s the point of a counsel boat without a full windshield?
Comparison:
Full Windshield – I spent years on Mille Lacs with a full windshield boat. It is great for cold/windy days. Being able to tuck behind the windshield is invaluable on these days.
Tiller – Fishing machine! The amount of room you have for fishing is night and day compared to a full windshield or counsel. Boat control is everything for fishing walleyes, tillers are top notch here. Cold/windy days can be brutal in a tiller, but the fishabilty makes up for it.
I switched from a full windshield to a tiller about 10 years ago and I’ll never look back. Good luck on your search!