All of you guys sound like you are trying to scare the poor guy off. It all depends on what you want to catch at Davis. As gwalter said you can always catch the 4-6″ crappie in the flooded timber. But at the same time that 17″ crappie might just decide he wants your jig also.
The year of the “WALLEYE EXPLOSION” at Davis, in my opinion, coincided with the loss of a great number of alewife from Calamus. Since the alewife have not endured and the shad have, the fishery has changed dramatically.
As others have said Davis is a lot like Elwood. The drastic dropoffs and extreme draw downs make for some real chances for precision fishing. In the early days of the lake we used to troll it with chartruese shadraps and just kill the walleyes; today you are better off picthing jigs to the points or slabbing the drops.
Davis is a challenge; but that is why we fish isn’t it?