I agree, it’s a total crapshoot. I’ve had bluebird weather in the A season and I’ve been snowed/rained/drowned out like a rat in both the A and B seasons.
The overriding concern that makes me choose the A season is hunting pressure. I do not have an abundance of turkeys in my area, so being the first to get at them is a huge advantage. Also, I think the peak of the breeding season is actually before the hunting season starts so the earlier you go, the more aggressive the birds are likely to be.
Also, I strongly suspect that because hunters are allowed to wear camo, there is a lot of trespassing going on and it fruther spooks the birds. Guys are sneaking on to land they don’t have permission to hunt because it’s very hard for a landowner to spot a turkey hunter out in the middle of a section. Even after firing a shot, it’s pretty easy for a tresspasser to grab the downed bird and disappear.
Hit the right weather and it can be beautiful. Hit the wrong weather and it can be almost unhuntable.
Grouse