The <strong class=”ido-tag-strong”>crappie thing in Mille Lacs is really a mystery. I have heard rumors of enormous slabs in the southern bays and backwaters after ice out. In 2011 my Grandfather caught a couple back in Isle Bay that were 15 and 18 inches. He didn’t think an 18 inch <em class=”ido-tag-em”>crappie was anything special either.
Did you see a picture? I’ve heard about the elusive 17-18 inch crappie on Mille Lacs all my life and I’ve never seen any evidence they ever exist. I’ve never seen a mount or a photo. I’ve seen thousands of crappies in that lake, and I’ve never seen one over 15 inches. In fact, I’ve only seen 1 over 14.5 inches and it was a 15 incher I personally caught.
I’ve heard many people talk about 17 inch crappies yet no one can ever provide any evidence. What I have witnessed is someone catches a 14.5 inch crappie on Mille Lacs and think it’s a 16 or 17 incher. That’s very common. I’m not saying they don’t exist, but until I see a photo or a mount, or I catch one myself, I don’t believe it.
That being said, I wouldn’t waste my time targeting crappies. Even if you know where to catch them, it’s a crap shoot. They also aren’t as big as everyone thinks they are. If you want action and you’re committed to Mille Lacs, pick a southern bay and target pike. The amount of big pike in that lake is extraordinary and it’s a very underutilized fishery. Lots of fish in that 28-36 inch class with fish upwards and over 40 inches. Put out tip ups with sucker minnows, and if you want allot of action, drill holes and jig for all the 6-8 inch perch your heart desires.