Marine sealant of choice

  • Nate Northup
    Madison, WI area
    Posts: 225
    #1802269

    Hey folks!

    Picked up a new transducer to replace ny old non-working one, and gonna have to put a few new holes in the transom. What’s the best choice for sealing the mount and the old holes?

    Thanks for the advice!

    Nate

    deertracker
    Posts: 9133
    #1802304

    3M 5200 is what a lot use I believe.
    DT

    munchy
    NULL
    Posts: 4885
    #1802309

    In all reality the standard exterior grade clear 100% Silicone is more than adequate for sealing screw holes. Just run the nozzle over the screw threads to fill them then screw them in place. Use screws to fill the old holes as well. Just make sure everything is stainless. Been doing this for 20 years without issue. A heck of a lot cheaper as well. You can find a small squeeze tube at the home center for a couple bucks.

    Eelpoutguy
    Farmington, Outing
    Posts: 10287
    #1802315

    Munchy, No issues with dis-similar metals?

    nhamm
    Inactive
    Robbinsdale
    Posts: 7348
    #1802337

    5200 takes a week to cure, and is permanent.

    PL Marine grade silicone has treated me well for years now. Suitable for above and below waterline. Found at home Depot.

    When I redid boat floor 5200 got put on livewell connections, new boat plug frame, aeroter housing, etc. Stuff you never want to deal with.

    munchy
    NULL
    Posts: 4885
    #1802339

    Munchy, No issues with dis-similar metals?

    You’ll never have a reaction with anything as long as you use stainless.

    And just so you know 5200 wouldn’t prevent those issues either.

    Charles
    Posts: 1908
    #1802371

    how about 3m 4200?

    Joe Scegura
    Alexandria MN
    Posts: 2758
    #1802390

    Before you try 5200 I’d read through this.

    Correction: 5200 Thread, some guy says it Failed…. some say user error.

    I’ve used Shoe Goo for years with great luck, but I’ve been using Automotive Goop recently and it is very nice as well. Clear, stays slightly pliable, sticks to anything and will not come off. It’s a great adhesive that’s also a sealant. It doesn’t take a week to cure and sticks to the boat no matter where you put it.

    chubby
    Bloomington
    Posts: 244
    #1802391

    5200 is the best marine sealant overall and is the pros choice.

    One thing to keep in mind with silicone is that is is almost impossible to remove completely and nothing will stick to silicone not even silicone.

    basseyes
    Posts: 2481
    #1802412

    In all reality the standard exterior grade clear 100% Silicone is more than adequate for sealing screw holes. Just run the nozzle over the screw threads to fill them then screw them in place. Use screws to fill the old holes as well. Just make sure everything is stainless. Been doing this for 20 years without issue. A heck of a lot cheaper as well. You can find a small squeeze tube at the home center for a couple bucks.

    Agreed, especially if everything is cleaned and done properly.

    B-man
    Posts: 5710
    #1802417

    Do yourself a favor and mount a transducer board over the old holes.

    I like 5200, but Marine Goop works nice too.

    pool2fool
    Inactive
    St. Paul, MN
    Posts: 1709
    #1802421

    Before you try 5200 I’d read through this.

    5200 Failed

    I’ve used Shoe Goo for years with great luck, but I’ve been using Automotive Goop recently and it is very nice as well. Clear, stays slightly pliable, sticks to anything and will not come off. It’s a great adhesive that’s also a sealant. It doesn’t take a week to cure and sticks to the boat no matter where you put it.

    The OP in that thread stated that he didn’t properly clean/prep the surface before applying the 5200, and he didn’t observe the full 7-day cure time before getting it wet. I don’t see how this is product failure as opposed to simple user error?

    Part of the problem with 5200 in my opinion is in the branding/labeling as they called it a “Marine Adhesive Sealant.” Personally I only use 5200 as a sealant and never as an adhesive. I’ve had great results with Marine Goop as an adhesive and I stick with 3M 5200 as a below-the-water-line sealant only.

    Pauleye
    Onamia
    Posts: 276
    #1802424

    When I put on my trim tabs I used 5200 to fill the holes. No problems yet.

    Nate Northup
    Madison, WI area
    Posts: 225
    #1802425

    Thanks guys.

    Another question for ya:

    After unboxing my new unit, I saw the included power cable is only about 2 feet long. I need another 6-8 ft to reach my battery. Just got off the phone with support and the guy told me to splice in an extension of 22AWG…to me that seems awful small. Should I just go with something bigger like 16AWG to be safe or will the 22 be fine?

    The unit is a Garmin Striker Plus 9sv.

    B-man
    Posts: 5710
    #1802448

    Thanks guys.

    Another question for ya:

    After unboxing my new unit, I saw the included power cable is only about 2 feet long. I need another 6-8 ft to reach my battery. Just got off the phone with support and the guy told me to splice in an extension of 22AWG…to me that seems awful small. Should I just go with something bigger like 16AWG to be safe or will the 22 be fine?

    The unit is a Garmin Striker Plus 9sv.

    I’d go overkill (like 12-14 gauge) for future use. You or the next owner might want to add another graph or 12 volt outlet. It will cost a few bucks more, but when it comes to wire, bigger is better.

    404 ERROR
    MN
    Posts: 3918
    #1802451

    Permatex Ultra Black! My pops always said that if RTV and Duct Tape can’t fix it, it’s a goner.

    I’ve used shoe goo also, works fine.

    Joe Scegura
    Alexandria MN
    Posts: 2758
    #1802466

    I don’t see how this is product failure as opposed to simple user error?

    It was the title of the OP post dude? I just attached the link to a similar conversation about 5200. There’s helpful info in there that I thought should be included. I modified the link name for you. Carry on coffee

    pool2fool
    Inactive
    St. Paul, MN
    Posts: 1709
    #1802476

    <div class=”d4p-bbt-quote-title”>pool2fool wrote:</div>
    I don’t see how this is product failure as opposed to simple user error?

    It was the title of the OP post dude? I just attached the link to a similar conversation about 5200. There’s helpful info in there that I thought should be included. Carry on coffee

    My post wasn’t intended to attack you, or the OP. I realize that was part of the thread title, but sharing it by that brief headline is basically like sharing a fake story on Facebook.

    Jonesy
    Posts: 1148
    #1802566

    I’m the op from the other thread. The 5200 held up fine on the hull it did not adhere to the mounting board. I did Jo surface prep other than cleaning it with dish soap and water and drying it off.

    I redid everything with shoegoo and it has held up great.

    milemark_714
    Posts: 1285
    #1802602

    I have filled old holes with JB Weld,and use the Goop as mentioned to seal new screws.0 issues.

Viewing 22 posts - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.