I have an ’07 2010 Pro Guide that I use almost exclusively on Mille Lacs and could not be more happy with it. The hull handles anything that Mille Lacs can dish out and more. Speeds are 51-52 every day on a 1 foot chop. I won’t say it’s a dry boat, especially when quartering waves, but I’ve learned how to drive it better every year and can generally give my passengers a smooth dry ride out and back.
I have a 175 Opti and a Mill Kota Vector on the back, a Terrova on the front, and have not found a situation on the lake where I can’t do exactly what I want to do. The Terrova handles trolling up to 2.5 MPH up to a moderate chop, and when that isn’t enough the Opti takes over. If I want to get down to 2.0 with the 175 I drop a small 20 inch trolling bag off the front to slow down a bit more. There have been times where I thought a kicker would be nice, but honestly I haven’t ever been able to justify the extra weight and maintenance of it.
I have a Minn Kota alternator charger rigged which tops off my trolling batteries when I am running the main motor and have never arrived back at the dock with less than a 50% charge on the trolling batts due to the extra charging boost they receive when I am running around between trolling passes.
In heavy waves, being able to park on a spot and lindy rig with the 175 is huge. I have literally seen everyone else blown off spots, taking waves over the back, while I sit there comfortable pinned exactly where I want to be. The splashwell will occasionally take a big wave and fill up, but water drains out quickly and never reaches the bilge.
Every year I go to the Boat Show and look at the new offerings, and I have yet to see a boat that can do anything my current one won’t, so I plan to just keep running it. I did upgrade from Lowrance LCX units to Birds last year, and that was a great move as well.
There are a few other very good tiller boats out there for sure, but you will be very happy with the 2010 Pro Guide. Don’t skimp on your batteries, electronics, or trolling motors and you will have a great rig that will serve you well for many years.