JT Rogue versus JT Panhandler

  • gonehunting
    Posts: 535
    #2044340

    Looking for a good perch/crappie ice rod? I’m not familiar with these two rods. Which would be a better choice? To me the spring bobber is not a make or break. I have the gold digger and black reign for walleye. Thanks in advance for any opinions.

    jbg1219
    NW Iowa
    Posts: 654
    #2044353

    IIRC the panhandler is lighter action through out and excels while crappie fishing. Very light tip and easily able to detect the up-bite. I have them both and use the rogue for perch and the panhandler for crappie and gills. I do use a bigger, more aggressive jig for the perch and fish for them where jumbos are common. The panhandler does not handle the larger jig very well.

    bigstorm
    Southern WI
    Posts: 1446
    #2044392

    I prefer a fiberglass rod for panfish (crappies and gills) so I would lean toward the Rogue. That said, I havent seen the Rogue in person so I cant compare it to my other glass noodle rods regarding sensitivity

    Gary
    Posts: 62
    #2044752

    Check out the 35” panhandler with spring bobber. It’s a great rod.

    It’s just a longer panhandler with a spring bobber on it. Doubles as a good dead stick rod for walleye for value.

    For slightly heavier jigs and spoons for crappie hard to beat a TUCR bull whip.

    Panhandler for light/finesse is my favorite rod. Value in it can double as a dead stick. My grandkids have caught mid 20” walleye with this rod.

    Cameron white
    Posts: 516
    #2044927

    I enjoyed the gold digger for perch this past year, I have a 44” Elliot light/fast coming this fall.

    bigcrappie
    Blaine
    Posts: 4304
    #2045021

    GoneHunting, If you not game on spending $120 on a ice rod Message me. I custom build similar for far less.

    Matt Johnston
    Pine city
    Posts: 30
    #2048149

    Check out hogs back custom rods for all your needs! Great rods for anything you need.

    SoDak Fisher Guy
    Eastern SD
    Posts: 136
    #2048756

    Get a Thorne Bros Perch Sweetheart….they’ve been building rods a hell of alot longer than JT.

    Cameron white
    Posts: 516
    #2048785

    Get a Thorne Bros Perch Sweetheart….they’ve been building rods a hell of alot longer than JT.

    It’s personal preference. I sold my Thorne. Too stiff. I like the jt, but the Elliott is incredible.

Viewing 9 posts - 1 through 9 (of 9 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.