Isle Royale 7/31-8/2

  • M. Leslie
    Twin Cities
    Posts: 37
    #1557810

    LS forum around here seems bit dead so far this season (eerily like much of fishing along the N. Shore to this point), so here’s a trip report from our run out to IR this past weekend.

    Had not been out to Isle Royale for 20+ years so, like a child before Christmas, I could barely sleep for nearly a week in anticipation of finally retuning to the island.

    My friend Kyle and I headed out on Friday morning in my 20′ Grady along with another friend who was bravely bringing his teenage son and 78 y/o father along in his 22′ Sea Ray. Largely uneventful if not somewhat wet crossing in 2-3′ waves (should have put up the canvas) and after a brief detour to take some photos out by Rock of Ages, we rounded the channel buoys into Siskiwit Bay around 10 AM and set out to find a campsite. Found an empty shelter at the Siskiwit Bay campground and set up shop there.

    Fished for 4-5 hours that afternoon working the SW shore of the island from the bay back towards Feldtmann Head going 9/11. Nice ratio of Redfins in the mix, average size was 6-10# with only one large fish approaching the upper teens. Most of the fish came in 40-50 FOW and nearly all of them were picked off the top of the humps and reefs that litter the area. Our most consistent rods were: chrome dodger and green/chart SnG, purple/white spoon with pink dots, white/red bloody nose spoon and a copper watermelon FB. Surface temps were in the mid 40’s and the fish didn’t seem too interested in chasing their meal, as everything came tight to the bottom off of the riggers or 7-8 colors. Think one laker hit a stickbait on our 3 color, but everything else came on 7+ colors or bottom hugging riggers.

    Despite a forecast for 10 kt winds and 1′ seas on Saturday, we awoke to the same 15-18 kt winds and SW 2-3′ chop we dealt with on Friday, which would only get worse as the day progressed. We headed out Sat morning and worked the most productive area from Friday, but the water had cooled overnight to 40-41 degrees and we found the fishing much slower. Tried a little shallower and a little deeper without any improvement. Boat control was getting to be an issue as the waves built and trying to fish tight to the bottom without snagging and hanging up was starting to become a losing battle. After donating our fair share of tackle to Lake Superior and losing what was probably the largest fish of the weekend 20′ behind the boat, we headed in for an early lunch after only going 3/6.

    We decided to seek out some warmer water for the afternoon session and had noticed some 50 degree water at the entrance to Siskiwit Bay as we ran back to camp for lunch. Accordingly, we decided to stay in the bay when we headed back out as it would also afford some more protection from the winds/seas that were now gusting into the mid-20’s. Sat afternoon we trolled the SW shore of Siskiwit Bay and out towards Redfin Island where we found a nice swath of 50-52 degree water. The fishing improved in the warmer water and we salvaged the day with an 8/10 afternoon including a nice ~7# Chinook that may be my personal best on Superior.

    The king hit an orange crush spoon on a mono board line and immediately took the outer board skimming across the surface towards the shore. After about a 25 yard run, the board went under and didn’t reappear for several minutes. No idea how we didn’t lose that fish, as despite freespooling the reel several times to get the board to pop back up it just wouldn’t. The board finally surfaced barely 10 yards from shore and I was finally able to get the counter going in the right direction. Not surprisingly after towing my TX-22 around under the surface for 5 minutes, that Chinook was pretty gassed so didn’t have a lot of spunk left in him by the time we got the board off and to the net.

    I had planned to fish at least a half day on Sunday before heading back to the mainland, but unfortunately the guys in the other boat really wanted to get up and head straight back. Naturally, we awoke on Sunday morning to find a beautiful flat lake with only some slow rollers, so as much as it pained me to do it, we broke camp early and were back at the dock in GP by 9:15.

    Overall, it was a good trip. I was a bit disappointed in the smaller than expected average size of the Lakers and the fact that we never tied into any upper 30’s or 40″ fish, but undoubtedly my expectations were set a bit too high for not having not fished the island in so long. One thing is for certain- It will certainly not be another 20 years before I return the next time!

    Attachments:
    1. DSC00046.jpeg

    2. DSC00029-9.11.20-AM.jpg

    3. IMG_5121.jpeg

    4. IMG_5165.jpeg

    5. DSC00015.jpeg

    6. DSC00021.jpg

    7. 20150801_114819.jpg

    8. DSC00019.jpeg

    loonswail
    Ankeny, IA
    Posts: 237
    #1557819

    Awesome! Nice pics.

    Ralph Wiggum
    Maple Grove, MN
    Posts: 11764
    #1557822

    Sweet. IR is on my bucket list.

    biggill
    East Bethel, MN
    Posts: 11321
    #1557900

    Great report. I’m happy to say I’m headed there on Friday and Saturday!

    What size spoons worked best for you? I see that James reported small 3.5″ white backed spoons were the ticket.

    M. Leslie
    Twin Cities
    Posts: 37
    #1557914

    Have fun Biggill, hopefully you’ll have some calmer seas! Was definitely fishable for us, just had to work harder running the boat than we would have liked.

    Saw the same report from James so we did run some white-backed spoons as well as some copper spoons as another friend had reported luck with those as well (over standard silver). Copper and white took fish about equally and smaller spoons did seem to out perform mag size spoons for us. However the white/red bloody nose spoon took several fish and was a mag size.

    I will say that my “big three” go-to laker killers were completely dead for us the whole trip, those being: mag Agent Orange, mag Atomic Melon, and Jim’s FB ’57 Chevy.

    biggill
    East Bethel, MN
    Posts: 11321
    #1557918

    I will say that my “big three” go-to laker killers were completely dead for us the whole trip, those being: mag Agent Orange, mag Atomic Melon, and Jim’s FB ’57 Chevy.

    Very good to know. I might keep the Chevy in the box til I start changing colors. I’ve got a few coppers and the bloody nose so I’ll probably be putting those down first. I don’t have riggers so I’m hoping that they’ll be reachable in 90′ or less.

    Looking like a breezy day on Friday so I’m hoping that it doesn’t get too bad. It’s supposed to be outta the E or NE. Never been out there with a stiff wind from those directions. It sounds like the SW wind is the worst?

    James Holst
    Keymaster
    SE Minnesota
    Posts: 18926
    #1557948

    I will say that my “big three” go-to laker killers were completely dead for us the whole trip, those being: mag Agent Orange, mag Atomic Melon, and Jim’s FB ’57 Chevy.

    Very good to know. I might keep the Chevy in the box til I start changing colors. I’ve got a few coppers and the bloody nose so I’ll probably be putting those down first. I don’t have riggers so I’m hoping that they’ll be reachable in 90′ or less.

    Looking like a breezy day on Friday so I’m hoping that it doesn’t get too bad. It’s supposed to be outta the E or NE. Never been out there with a stiff wind from those directions. It sounds like the SW wind is the worst?

    A NE / EAST wind is a bad direction if you’re going out to the island as you’ll have the rollers coming into your face the whole way. A SW wind is one of the worst for coming back.

    Be safe out there and let us know how you do. I got a report from some friends that fished up there last week out of Little Todd that did really, really well on both lakers and salmon. I think I’m about two weeks away from being able to get back to Superior so in the short term I’ll be living vicariously through your follow up report when you get back!

    ssperch
    Hudson, WI
    Posts: 175
    #1557988

    Thanks for the report, Magnus! Those pictures are great. I’m going to have to add an Isle Royal trip to my bucket list. Nice Lake Superior King!!

    Sam

    biggill
    East Bethel, MN
    Posts: 11321
    #1558050

    Be safe out there and let us know how you do. I got a report from some friends that fished up there last week out of Little Todd that did really, really well on both lakers and salmon. I think I’m about two weeks away from being able to get back to Superior so in the short term I’ll be living vicariously through your follow up report when you get back!

    Thanks for the tip. It might be a good option with an E wind. Saturday looks like the better day right now.

    James Holst
    Keymaster
    SE Minnesota
    Posts: 18926
    #1558130

    Be safe out there and let us know how you do. I got a report from some friends that fished up there last week out of Little Todd that did really, really well on both lakers and salmon. I think I’m about two weeks away from being able to get back to Superior so in the short term I’ll be living vicariously through your follow up report when you get back!

    Thanks for the tip. It might be a good option with an E wind. Saturday looks like the better day right now.

    I just took a look at the wave forecast and assuming the wind direction and velocity stay as forecast you should be in good shape for a weekend trip. Good luck!

    Allan Davis
    Carlton, MN
    Posts: 415
    #1558364

    Has anyone fished the lakes on the Island. I heard an old timer say that they have done awesome on some of the lakes for brookies and other trout.

Viewing 13 posts - 1 through 13 (of 13 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.