I’ve owned two Jiffys and two Strikemasters, and countless hand augers (including a Nils). I’ve used a Nils and an eskimo power auger from friends also. I’m a firm believer that anyone can get a lemon, sometimes even more than one, with the manufacturer not necessarily being directly at fault. In today’s market, so much is farmed out to ancillary companies, it’s difficult to say SM/Jiffy is responsible for the performance of the powerhead for example. However, it’s always the parent company’s responsibility to stand behind the total package, and typically to cover their customers. That said, I think you need to compare overall performance/features over several or more augers, and many points of view.
Strikemaster offers just about any auger a person could want, chipper or shaver, in extremely lightweight offerings, that are durable over the long haul, with easy to find replacement blades/parts, from a local (MN) company, with excellent customer service. In a nutshell, that’s why I run them. Is it the fastest on the ice? My lazer mag with sharp blades is darned fast I’ll tell you that. Will I win speed competitions? Maybe. I don’t know? But that doesn’t matter to me.
For long, my opinions regarding Nils have been censored, and I truly wish not to bash or offend those that like them. However, I cannot recommend this product. I was present when a group of Nils users were installing a larger injection port (aftermarket) to increase gas flow and improve idling/auger speed. This was because of the break-in period issues, as well as problems that required idling up to a minute before usage (those times weren’t figured into the auger races).
While I’m uncertain as to the status of this problem, I do know that with a Nils I’d need to spend more money than about any other auger on the market, and would have to buy/carry a replacement cutting head at about $70. You’d be silly not to, as on more than one occasion, I’ve dulled blades beyond usage with sand, rock, or dinging them. To get these blades fixed/resharpened then, you have to send them away and wait for their return rather than purchase them off of any bait shop shelf.
If I break a recoil, needed a tune-up, or had issues with the powerhead, I’d have to go to a Tanaka dealer or small-engine repair shop. Instead, I go to Strikemaster HQ in Big Lake and they take care of me while I wait, for half the price of a small engine repair shop.
I’ll tell you right now, front and center that I work with Strikemaster, and there’s a good reason that I do. It’s because I’ve owned and ran their augers long before I ever made their pro-staff; for all the reasons listed above and then some.
Joel