I generally start with a 1/4oz rattling spoon on one rod and a dead-sticked glow demon on the other rod. A good old buckshot is hard to beat as a cheap easy to fish spoon. From there, I adjust occasionally based on what I learn if I have fish marked who don’t hit. Everyone has their favorite colors – but gold, pink, and bright uv combinations are frequently out of my tacklebox.
I personally think LOTW is one of the few places where you can often choose how you want to fish and catch fish versus how you have to fish to catch fish. I’ve got some friends who swear by jigging raps, slab raps, etc while others will fish 2 deadsticks if others in the house are using more aggressive baits. I think being on fish is infinitely more important to success than what lures/baits are used on a huge body like LOTW.