boats are a study in compromise. would i like a boat that can handle 4′ waves one minute and swing bass over the sides in the next? sure, but that doesn’t exist, so we have to choose the thing that best fits how we’ll use the boat 95% of the time.
i owned 3 different Tuffy X-190s. it’s a very light hull with a high-performance (bassboat style) running pad which makes it exceptionally fast: ~65mph with a 200hp Opti. the front deck is huge, but it’s not that common to fish two up front anyway. the cockpit quickly gets crowded with people and gear, especially if the rear deck insert is installed. it’s long enough to handle large water fairly well, but it’s not a big water boat by any means if the weather starts blowing. i speared a few waves both while running and trolling that a different hull would have smashed or rolled over; being light and fast is less than ideal in those conditions. the ride is good in waves up to 1.5′, choppy but fun in 2’ers, and requires skillful driving beyond that. it offers very good access to the water and a slow drift rate due to the low freeboard height.
i don’t think the MX1825 is very comparable to the X-190, largely due to the impact that length has: neither have deep hulls so the longer boat will definitely ride better. the 1825’s small deck is crowded for guiding two clients, but when fishing 2 guys in the boat like most of us do most of the time, it’s plenty big for the guy up front and offers additional cockpit space for storage and trolling comforts. with a relatively shallow/flat hull, it’s ride quality will clearly be affected by it’s length but offer good access to shallow areas. the MX2025 is longer yet so would offer a better ride and fishability for more people at once. the MX2025 is probably the most appealing “hybrid” boat available out there right now from my perspective.
i spend a couple weeks each year on LotW, casting in summer and trolling late fall, and then various short trips to big MN lakes or WI great lakes water. for me, being able to go where i want when i want became the most important thing, so i moved from the X-190 to a WX2000T, and now to a WX1910. as a muskie fisherman i used to drink the kool-aide that being close to the water was extra important. but now i’ve got 9’6″ rods, so 6″ closer to the water really isn’t that much, and it’s much less important than it was just 10 years ago. at the same time, that extra freeboard and deep-v depth really matters when running around and the big cockpit is great for trolling or panfishing with the family. plus, with the new boat being a bit shorter it fits in my garage…