Keep in mind that there’s no exact way to get an answer. You can’t look up comps as you can with real estate sales.
IMO, that close to the Twin Cities and assuming firearms deer season only, I think if you got exclusive access to that kind of acerage for $1000, you’d be doing very well. I assume you’re splitting this with other hunters.
Obviously, even better if you could get it for less, but it could just as easily be much more depending on what the owner knows about other leases in the area. I’d negotiate carefully. As others have suggested, start by trying to get some intel about what the other party is thinking without throwing out a figure too early.
In cases of hunting land, there’s an opportunity cost. How many other parcels of land are for lease in the same area? Probably damn few. “Worth” is a very slippery term because it depends on your motivation as well as how deep are your pockets. If I had nowhere else to hunt, I can tell you that I’d pay even more than $1000 for a lease >60 ac. in that area, but that’s just me.
Grouse