Ever since the end of the 2008 season, I had been second guessing myself for passing on deer that would have easily been my biggest deer but was looking for something that didn’t leave me wondering about a shoot/no shoot decision.
As we began setting trail cam pics in 2009, we immediately began to see some nice deer. I truly believed that at least one of the two big 8’s I had passed on in 2008 had made it through the year.
My stands from 08 were still in the same trees. I was not able to get down to the land to move them and help clear trails on Labor Day weekend as my family and I took a trip. I was able to get down there in mid October. I have two stands on this land that are both what we call “over the edge” as we hunt the backside of the steep MI river bluffs in WI’s Buffalo County. From our parking spot at the top of the hill we have @ 100 yards of forest before “the edge”. I do not attempt to get to either stand in the dark, it is far too treacherous. I am also the only person in our group who will hunt on the hillsides. All others hunt the top or bottoms.
I took the stand I simply refer to as stand 1 down and repositioned it in another tree close by with a better view and also with the help of a pulley system I found at Gander, was able to get it much higher up in the tree. I shoot lefty so I made sure the majority of the likely deer paths were accessible to a left handed shooter. I found stand 2 and mounted a camera arm to the tree so I could film from this stand. It was at this stand I saw the bigger of the two 8’s in 08.
Now the wait was on, gun week finally came and I was ready to go. Thursday night, an open seat was posted for P4 so I got in some eye fishing on my way down to Cochrane. Got down to the cabin @3:30, made sure the gun was still sighted in, entered the big buck contest at the Waumandee House, had a great meal with good friends, and the 2009 season was a short nights sleep away.
I remember driving down to Cochrane after fishing and thinking, no two seasons are the same, the chances of you seeing those two big bucks again are slim, this season will bring a new surprise, a new story. I enjoy that drive from Hudson to Cochrane every year. I love the drive along the MI river bluffs and my tradition is to listen to Kenny Chesney’s “When the Sun goes down” CD. Back to the real story.
Fog is forecasted for the opening morning. With our cabin being at the bottom of the hill, it was very foggy at the cabin. My hope was that up higher it would be less. Initially this was the case but by 7:45, the fog moved up the hill and I was completely socked in. I stayed in this stand until 9:30, 2 hours longer than I wanted to. I wanted to be in stand one, 1/2 hour after sunrise. I saw the hunters from the neighboring property return to their truck right by mine so I returned to the truck and have a chat. Nothing moving by them either, too foggy, when will this fog move out. I had heard by 11:00. In talking, I found out that last year they had bagged a big 8 pointer. Very symmetrical was how they described it. Based on where their stands were and likely routes, I felt heavy hearted that they had bagged the bigger of the two I had passed on. Oh well, there’s two big ones I’m after this year, both 10’s, one that was very symmetrical and the other I called twister as his right front antler twisted down and toward the middle of his rack.
I took a nap in the truck for 30 minutes and headed for stand 1 about 10:15. I had not been to this stand since October, so I had some tinkering to do. Got the padded seat put on, the arm rests, tied up a rope to get my gun up and down, etc. About 15-20 minutes worth of tinkering. The fog was lifting.
I got up in my stand, strapped in, binocs on their rung, pulled up my gun, snapped in the clip, chambered a shell and I was finally hunting again. 10:40 am or so. Now that the fog was lifting, it was turning into a beautiful day. Squirrels started playing near my stand, which is both good and bad.
About 20 minutes later, I heard a sound behind my stand, expecting another squirrel I turned, I’m sure about this time I looked like the fisherman in Caddyshack as Rodney Dangerfield’s boat was barreling down on him eyes bulging out of his head. Thankfully I didn’t do anything rash. All I could see were antler’s, great big antler’s reaching for the sky!!! In all my time hunting, fishing, this was THE most beautiful sight I’ve ever seen in nature.
Unfortunately, it wouldn’t last long, he had me as well in my turn. He quickly jumped off and I began to think about cracking off a quick shot. He was behind me but to my right, if on the other side, shooting lefty would not have been possible. He looked back to check me out, then he jumped a downed tree in his path, keeping me in sight all the time, coming slighly down hill but angling away from me. He did not run. I noticed his hair was ruffed up on the side facing me.
He stopped again and it was now or never. He was within 20 yards of the property line, boom! I knew I hit him, the shot was only 30-40 yards. He ran straight downhill, never crossing the line, very fast, and tumbled after 40 yards, came to rest next to a tree, within my plain view and less than 40 yards from the stand. I started breathing again but it was in short, I’m almost out of breath, my heart is going to come out of my chest breaths!
When I regained composure, I first called in the shot to the others in the woods who assumed it was me. I could barely form sentences. I started texting, my wife, a few friends from Hudson who were in the big buck contest with me, Suzuki – who had sent me a text on Friday while we were preparing for the hunt.
As I got down out of the stand, I grabbed the video camera I had planned to use in stand 2, video’d the route the deer took, and video’d my approach to the deer and several first looks at the biggest buck of my life.
We got the 4-wheeler amazingly close and up the hill toward this deer and I was able to drive him out of the woods.
After getting that deer out of the woods so everyone else could continue to hunt, I got him over to a corner of the farm and started to field dress him. As I was clearing out the chest cavity, I saw something sticking through his ribcage, it was a broadhead!
I had read earlier in the week to be careful when field dressing a deer in case you ran into a broken off broadhead, what are the chances. So I knew now why his hair was ruffed on the one side. The rage 3 was sticking through the rib cage @ 1″ into the vitals, but no further. It had about 2 inches of arrow attached to it.
I grabbed a pliers off the 4-wheeler and pulled the broadhead through. More on this later.
I got him into Waumandee to get registered and weighed at the Waumandee House for the contest. Just shy of 160 lbs. field dressed. They took my picture and off I went. I was on for cooking that night since I was largely done hunting.
When the rest of the hunting crew came back in it was high fives and many pats on the back. One member of our party is local to the area and when I showed him the broadhead, he knew who likely had taken the shot. He left with the broadhead and went to find this hunter. About an hour later, we got a call in the cabin from the hunter and his group who had shot a 10 pointer on Nov. 1, and never found a trace of blood. They wanted to come and see it.
This group hunts the property immediately to our east and when they arrived he was amazed at the deer and took several pics. He was very glad it had been harvested and had not died in the woods. He had looked for a blood trail for hours and never found a single drop. He was truly bummed that he had hit such a beautiful deer and did not kill it.
We also pulled a trail cam that we had not checked since late October and found over 50 pictures of this deer and you can see now that we knew where to look, that he had been arrowed. The pictures were all from November 5th, 6th, and 7th.
This deer’s rack was measured and scored @ 145″ He had very good mass which really helped him score. I am doing a horn mount on a stand normally used for a european mount. I will include a photo album on the mount with all the trail cam pics and post harvest pics along with my spent shell casing. If I can get the broadhead back, I’d like to include it as well.
Now I can sleep easy, knowing I did not have to second guess the shot, that I was fortunate to harvest such a beautiful deer. I truly believe this was the 1st deer I passed on in 2008. It was on the same route, showed up at the same time (first light in 08, just when the fog lifted in 09).
I believe there to be some fate involved as well. I passed on this deer, it survived a winter, summer, and fall, was arrowed and survived to allow me the chance to see him again! I consider myself very fortunate for this opportunity and will have this memory for the rest of my life!
Thanks for reading and I hope the WI deer situation improves quickly, despite my recent success with this deer, it was the ONLY deer I saw in 2009!!
Here’s looking forward to 2010!!!
Eric