Hey Scott, congratulations on your decision to try traditional! It’s a lot of fun and a very rewarding way of life! I’ve hunted with a recurve most of the 28 years I’ve been shooting bows (tried the “dark-side” with a compound and find it not to be nearly as enjoyable as with a simple stick-n-string)….to each their own, though! I agree with much of what FishCrazy suggested, with the exception of using wood arrows! I know he meant if you’re going to go traditional why not go all the way and use wood arrows, but DON”T DO IT!!!! Atleast not yet, and I’ll tell you why….Instinctive style of shooting requires more practice and greater concentration on form and follow-thru. At this point in the game that is what you need to master, your form, anchor-point, and follow-thru. You want to elimate anthing that can get in the way of that and erode your confidence. You don’t want to have to worry about which wood species, what spine, keeping your arrows straight, checking them regularaliy….forget about that until you have developed your shooting ability and can consistanly hit your target out to 20 yards…..THEN, and only then, get yourself some wood arrows! I used aluminum because it is readily available everywhere, fairly inexpensive, and is consistant in spine and weight. A few good sizes to start with would be 2016,2018,2117, depending on your draw weight, which brings me to what I feel to be the biggest factor in whether or not you enjoy shooting traditional. I HIGHLY recommend that whatever weight you shot on your compound that you NOT buy a recurve that less than 20 pounds lighter!!!!!!!!!! Being over-bowed is the single worst thing you can do at this stage of the game. You need a bow you can learn to shoot well and you can’t shoot well or with confidence if you are struggling to pull your bow back to anchor consistantly!!!!!!! A lot of ex-compound shooters make this mistake, I made it when I jumped back into the recurve. I don’t care if you can bench 350 pounds, you will be so happy if you get a 50-55 pound bow….atleast for now. It’s not a macho thing to pull more weight, nor is it neccessary. My 55lb. recurve will shoot right thru any North American game animal, I’m not even remotely concerned about it, nor should you be. Shooting a lighter bow and building up into something heavier will not only help your bowshooting abilities, but it will give you the confidence you need to stick with traditional….you can’t hit what you are looking at if you are struggling to pull your bow back or hold your anchor.
FishCrazy mentioned Traditional Bowhunter Magazine….it’s a great resource and I recommend you get a copy if you haven’t already! A few other excellent instuctional materials are G.Fred Asbell’s books and corresponding video, Shooting Instictively 1 & 2…..spend the $ and go to Gander or Cabelas and get them, they are excellent and you will learn more from them than I or anyone else can ever type in a post. Fred is very good at explaining why a recurve or longbow make a better hunting weapon than a compound, in a gentleman-like way and without bashing or fingerpointing, plus he’s a heck of a guy and a good writer! Give Lamont Granger a call at the Footed Shaft or go visit his shop in Rochester….he’s also a heck of a nice guy and probably the best resource in Minnesota for traditional information, bows, supplies, etc…his number is 507-288-7581. Lamont is a great guy and if you don’t listen to me about bow-weight and wood arrows, listen to him!
Good Luck, traditional archery, as they call it nowadays, is awesome! You will have to practise quite a bit more than you did with your compound, but the flight of the arrow and watching it as it flies to it’s mark is one of the most enjoyable passtimes a fellow can do! Let me know when you are shooting well and maybe we can plan a hunt together somewhere, I’m always up for a big-game hunt! If you ever have any questions or concerns about shooting a recurve or longbow, don’t hesitate to PM me. I’d be glad to help in any way I can. Part of the passion of traditional, for me, is helping other people enjoy it too!