I suggest you take the arm and shuttle to yrou hardware store to figure out what is needed. I did this to 3 of my ICE 55’s but would not even start to guess what size hardware is needed. I remember adding several washers as shims and so forth.
Head up into a smaller, quieter hardware store (ACE Hardware) and have at it! I’d brought armfuls of stuff in there to figure out what’s right. Just tell the clerk what the plan is.