I wouldn’t put myself in a position for them to come over and ruin my stuff. If I did give them the opportunity and they ruined something I wouldn’t blame them, I’d blame myself for giving them the opportunity. Or if they did it despite what I had communicated with them, then I’d have no problem confronting them
On the front end, he should have established if they can use the ATV’s or not. If you let a kid or irresponsible brother, use an ATV and then are upset they beat on it, that’s your own fault. Learn from it and move on. If you didn’t give them permission and they did it anyway, figure out what makes you whole, ask for it and learn to never leave them with access to any of your stuff again.
Depends on the history, if I had told them they were not allowed to drive without my permission, then I’d read them the riot act and discuss monetary compensation if I thought that would make it right. If I had given them permission to use the 4 wheelers previously and it was established that was fine, then that’s your/my own fault for not telling them not to now.
The way it’s always worked at our family cabins, is ground rules are set and that is the expectation moving forward. You can or can’t use XYZ equipment, and once you are allowed to use it, it’s not expected that every time you want to use it moving forward you need to check in with the owner.
@CaptainMusky maybe you missed these in all my previous posts, so I consolidated them down for you into one. Hope this helps bud!